Tartuca: Date Night at the Chef’s Counter

Tartuca, on Mississippi Ave
Tartuca, on Mississippi Ave

Date night on Mississippi Ave: cocktails at Stem Wine Bar first, then Tartuca, the little Italian spot with the tortoise on the sign. We lucked into seats at the chef’s counter, and I would take those seats every time. You watch the whole kitchen work, and every plate in the house parades past you on its way out. Half the fun was seeing what everyone else ordered.

The Atmosphere

The room is small, warm, and loud in the right way: open kitchen, bottles lining the walls, and that counter. Sitting there, dinner comes with a show. The focaccia loaves come out of the oven blistered and nearly blackened on top, trays of tiramisu slide past, and you start planning your next visit before you have finished the first one.

The chef's counter
The chef’s counter
The pass, where every plate goes by
The pass, where every plate goes by
The wine wall
The wine wall
The menu
The menu

The Food

We started with the housemade focaccia and added the burrata, because of course we did. The focaccia arrives thick and charred on top with a ramekin of olive oil, and the burrata gets spread right over it. Amazing.

Housemade focaccia and burrata
Housemade focaccia and burrata
That char on the focaccia
That char on the focaccia
The burrata
The burrata

The classic Caesar next: romaine, parmesan, croutons, done exactly the way a Caesar should be. Yep, amazing.

The classic Caesar
The classic Caesar

For mains we split the two pastas. The cavatelli comes with red wine braised pork shank, kale, giardiniera, and saffron, rich and a little spicy from the pickled vegetables. The gnudi are the soft ricotta kind, with fennel braised chicken, delicata squash puree, seared fennel, and fried sage. Both were delicious, and I would order the exact same thing again.

Cavatelli with braised pork shank
Cavatelli with braised pork shank
Gnudi with fennel braised chicken
Gnudi with fennel braised chicken

Dessert was simple: two glasses of limoncello. The right ending.

Limoncello for dessert
Limoncello for dessert

The Wine

With dinner we drank a Thomain Enfer d’Arvier 2024 from Italy’s Vallée d’Aoste, a red with a devil on the label (Enfer means hell, and the wine lives up to the branding in the best way). It held its own against the pork shank and the saffron.

Thomain Enfer d'Arvier 2024, Vallée d'Aoste
Thomain Enfer d’Arvier 2024, Vallée d’Aoste

My Rating

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5

Highlights

  • The chef’s counter: dinner and a show, with every plate in the house passing by
  • Housemade focaccia with the burrata add: charred, soft, and dangerous
  • Cavatelli with braised pork shank and giardiniera
  • Gnudi with fennel braised chicken and fried sage

Good to know

  • Book the counter if you can; it is the best seat in the house
  • The focaccia plus burrata is listed as an add-on (+$11 on the focaccia). Just do it
  • Tartuca is small and popular; our reservation got moved up 15 minutes the day of, so keep an eye on your phone
  • Mississippi Ave makes an easy full date night: Stem Wine Bar before, Tartuca for dinner, Madame Bar Bar after

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *